Senior Living in Bay Shore, NY
Also serving communities of Brentwood, Islip, East Islip.
There are 29 Senior Living options in the Bay Shore area, with 5 in Bay Shore and 24 nearby.
The average cost of senior living in Bay Shore is $7,645 per month. Cheaper nearby regions include West Babylon with an average starting cost of $6,669.
To help you with your search, browse the 207 reviews below for senior living in Bay Shore. On average, consumers rate senior living in Bay Shore 4.4 out of 5 stars. Better rated regions include Sayville with an average rating of 4.7 out of 5 stars.
Caring.com has helped thousands of families find high-quality senior care. To speak with one of our Family Advisors about senior living options and costs in Bay Shore, call (855) 863-8283.
5 Senior Living Options in Bay Shore, NY
Atria Bay Shore
Provides: Assisted Living, Independent Living, and Memory Care
53 Ocean Avenue, Bay Shore, NY 11706
"Atria Bay Shore was unbelievable. It was clean. The staff was well organized and polite. I had a great feeling about it. I felt very comfortable there. Everything smelled so good.
The staff was..." More
"Atria Bay Shore was unbelievable. It was clean. The staff was well organized and polite. I had a great feeling about it. I felt very comfortable there. Everything smelled so good.
The staff was..." More
Open Gate Association Home for the Aged
Provides: Assisted Living
36 South Clinton Avenue, Bay Shore, NY 11706
Caring Star 2022
The Arbors at Bohemia
Provides: Assisted Living
1065 Smithtown Avenue, Bohemia, NY 11716
"Arbors of Bohemia is a very intimately run facility. Staff and residents are very friendly. There are endless activities for the residents at the facility, plus planned activities off grounds. The..." More
Ask about our Heroes Welcome Program up to 5% off Select Accommodations. Heroes include Veterans,...
(more)
Ends in 36 days
"Arbors of Bohemia is a very intimately run facility. Staff and residents are very friendly. There are endless activities for the residents at the facility, plus planned activities off grounds. The..." More
Ask about our Heroes Welcome Program up to 5% off Select Accommodations. Heroes include Veterans,...
(more)
Ends in 36 days
Caring Star 2017
Sunrise of West Babylon
Provides: Assisted Living and Memory Care
580 Montauk Hwy, West Babylon, NY 11704
"I went to Sunrise of West Babylon. I saw all the rooms, the assisted living area, and the memory neighborhood. Both were shown to me. I did like the place. They just don't have a vacancy for my..." More
Please ask about our special incentives!
Ends in 220 days
"I went to Sunrise of West Babylon. I saw all the rooms, the assisted living area, and the memory neighborhood. Both were shown to me. I did like the place. They just don't have a vacancy for my..." More
Please ask about our special incentives!
Ends in 220 days
Gurwin Jewish - Fay J. Lindner Reside...
Provides: Assisted Living and Independent Living
50 Hauppauge Road, Commack, NY 11725
"I visited Gurwin Jewish for my sister. My mother lived at Gurwin Assisted Living until she died, and my husband is in Gurwin Rehab, so Gurwin has been in and remains in my family. I was in love..." More
"I visited Gurwin Jewish for my sister. My mother lived at Gurwin Assisted Living until she died, and my husband is in Gurwin Rehab, so Gurwin has been in and remains in my family. I was in love..." More
Caring Star 2016
The Arbors at Islandia East
Provides: Assisted Living and Memory Care
1515 Veteran’s Memorial Highway, Islandia, NY...
"The Arbors at Islandia East is fantastic and the staff is excellent. I looked at a 1-bedroom and it's very nice. They have bingo, exercise, and physical therapy. They also have a very beautiful..." More
"The Arbors at Islandia East is fantastic and the staff is excellent. I looked at a 1-bedroom and it's very nice. They have bingo, exercise, and physical therapy. They also have a very beautiful..." More
Ross Center for Health and Rehabilita...
Provides: Assisted Living and Nursing Homes
839 Suffolk Avenue, Brentwood, NY 11717
"I had a family member stay at Ross Center for Health & Rehabilitation. The rehab team is fantastic and hard working they had my uncle walking comfortably in just a few weeks. The place recently..." More
"I had a family member stay at Ross Center for Health & Rehabilitation. The rehab team is fantastic and hard working they had my uncle walking comfortably in just a few weeks. The place recently..." More
The Bristal at West Babylon
Provides: Assisted Living, Independent Living, and Memory Care
520 Montauk Highway, West Babylon, NY 11751
"I went to The Bristal at West Babylon. The rooms were very spacious and beautiful. The whole facility offered everything from A to Z. It was a wonderful facility. We didn't really meet a lot of..." More
"I went to The Bristal at West Babylon. The rooms were very spacious and beautiful. The whole facility offered everything from A to Z. It was a wonderful facility. We didn't really meet a lot of..." More
Maria Regina Residence Inc
Provides: Nursing Homes
1725 Brentwood Road, Brentwood, NY 11717
"My mother-in-law moved into Maria Regina Residence Inc. several months ago. It's a nursing home and so far, it's been excellent. The staff all seem to be very friendly and caring, both towards the..." More
"My mother-in-law moved into Maria Regina Residence Inc. several months ago. It's a nursing home and so far, it's been excellent. The staff all seem to be very friendly and caring, both towards the..." More
Affinity Skilled Living and Rehabilit...
Provides: Nursing Homes
305 LOCUST AVENUE, Oakdale, NY 11769
"My Dad who had to be transferred to Affinity from the V.A. was sent to Affinity. we were so scared after reading the reviews to that had been posted fooled us into believing the place was a dump is..." More
"My Dad who had to be transferred to Affinity from the V.A. was sent to Affinity. we were so scared after reading the reviews to that had been posted fooled us into believing the place was a dump is..." More
Gurwin Jewish Nursing & Rehabilitatio...
Provides: Assisted Living, Independent Living, Nursing Homes, Home Care, Adult Day Care, and Memory Care
68 Hauppauge Road, Commack, NY 11725
"My wife is in Gurwin Jewish Nursing & Rehabilitation Center. The place looks very modern. The staff is excellent. I haven't met a person there from the cleaning ladies to the head of the..." More
"My wife is in Gurwin Jewish Nursing & Rehabilitation Center. The place looks very modern. The staff is excellent. I haven't met a person there from the cleaning ladies to the head of the..." More
Berkshire Nursing And Rehab
Provides: Assisted Living and Nursing Homes
10 Berkshire Road , West Babylon, NY 11704
"Berkshire Nursing and Rehabilitation Center is more suited to my father. He requires nursing home care, and the staff is doing a good job. They're helping him with his needs. I don't have any..." More
"Berkshire Nursing and Rehabilitation Center is more suited to my father. He requires nursing home care, and the staff is doing a good job. They're helping him with his needs. I don't have any..." More
Our Lady of Consolation Geriatric Car...
Provides: Nursing Homes
111 BEACH DRIVE, West Islip, NY 11795
"My mother got excellent care from the entire staff at Our Lady of Consolation Geriatric Care Center West Islip. They were very attentive to her. The outside was very nice, we were only as far as..." More
"My mother got excellent care from the entire staff at Our Lady of Consolation Geriatric Care Center West Islip. They were very attentive to her. The outside was very nice, we were only as far as..." More
East Neck Nursing & Rehab Center
Provides: Nursing Homes
134 GREAT EAST NECK ROAD, West Babylon, NY 11704
"My entire experience from calling the admissions office to place my mother, to calling the Social Work department to discharge her was smooth and seamless. The admissions girls really helped calm..." More
"My entire experience from calling the admissions office to place my mother, to calling the Social Work department to discharge her was smooth and seamless. The admissions girls really helped calm..." More
Bayview Home for Adults
Provides: Assisted Living
143 East Main Street, Babylon, NY 11702
"I already have a place for my elderly cousin. I wasn't too happy then which is why I went online, but it has gotten a little better. So far it is OK. The name of the facility is Bayview Rest Home...." More
"I already have a place for my elderly cousin. I wasn't too happy then which is why I went online, but it has gotten a little better. So far it is OK. The name of the facility is Bayview Rest Home...." More
Babylon Beach House
Provides:
23 Yacht Club Road, Babylon, NY 11702
"I love Babylon Beach House's setting. It's beautiful, but it's a little city looking. The people were old, but everybody seemed happy and that's what I'm looking forward to. They were very..." More
"I love Babylon Beach House's setting. It's beautiful, but it's a little city looking. The people were old, but everybody seemed happy and that's what I'm looking forward to. They were very..." More
Brentwood Adult Home
Provides: Assisted Living, Nursing Homes, and Continuing Care Communities
147 Second Avenue, Brentwood, NY 11717
Elmore Home for Adults
Provides: Assisted Living, Independent Living, and Nursing Homes
330 Elmore Street, Central Islip, NY 11722
Maple Rest
Provides: Assisted Living, Nursing Homes, and Continuing Care Communities
61 Rollstone Avenue, West Sayville, NY 11796
Holiday Square - 55 And Above
Provides: Independent Living and Senior Apartment
10 Muncy Ave, West Babylon, NY 11704
"Welcome to Holiday Square! Every day will feel like a holiday at Holiday Square in West Babylon, NY! Our one-bedroom apartments for rent are perfect for active adults 55 years and over. At Holiday..." More
"Welcome to Holiday Square! Every day will feel like a holiday at Holiday Square in West Babylon, NY! Our one-bedroom apartments for rent are perfect for active adults 55 years and over. At Holiday..." More
Senior Living near Bay Shore, NY
Other Options in Bay Shore, NY
Recent Reviews of Senior Living in Bay Shore
-
Review of Atria Bay Shore
Atria Bay Shore was unbelievable. It was clean. The staff was well organized and polite. I had a great feeling about it. I felt very comfortable there. Everything smelled so good. The staff was v... Read more
-
Review of Atria Bay Shore
Atria Bayshore is farther away, which is the one issue, you know if I want to visit my parents. There was also an issue with the catheter. They would have the ability to change the bag, but not rem... Read more
-
Review of Atria Bay Shore
I would recommend the Atria in Bayshore to anyone looking for. Senior Residence on Long Island. From start to finish our experience has been first class. The staff made the interview process to cho... Read more
Senior Living near Suffolk County, NY
More Options Near Bay Shore, NY
Business owner? Claim your Caring.com Listing