The 10 Best Assisted Living Facilities in Bay Shore, NY for 2023

Also serving communities of Islip, Brentwood.

There are 15 Assisted Living Facilities in the Bay Shore area, with 2 in Bay Shore and 13 nearby.

The average cost of assisted living in Bay Shore is $7,095 per month. This is higher than the national median of $3,895.

To help you with your search, browse the 146 reviews below for assisted living facilities in Bay Shore. On average, consumers rate assisted living in Bay Shore 4.4 out of 5 stars. Better rated regions include West Babylon with an average rating of 4.4 out of 5 stars.

Caring.com has helped 9 families in Bay Shore find high-quality senior care. To speak with one of our Family Advisors about assisted living options and costs in Bay Shore, call (855) 948-3865.

Bay Shore, New York, is located in Suffolk County on Long Island. The city is home to Captree State Park, a lovely location for fishing, boating, and spending time outdoors. The population of Bay Shore is 30,000, with 11% being seniors aged 65 and older. This is a demographic that will probably need housing and care in assisted living communities as they age. To accommodate these individuals, Bay Shore has two assisted living facilities, with 12 more in nearby communities. 

• The overall cost of living in Bay Shore is 129 compared to the U.S. baseline of 100. While grocery costs and healthcare, both important to seniors in assisted living, are within a few points of the national average, the higher cost of housing, 170 compared to 100, raises the overall cost of living. This may mean that facilities charge more due to higher operating costs. 
  
• Income derived from Social Security is not subject to New York state income tax, which may be helpful to seniors on a budget. In addition, income from private pensions or other retirement accounts is tax exempt up to $20,000. 
• The Bay Shore area is home to world-class medical facilities, including Southside Hospital Northwell Health, in the event of medical emergencies or illness.
• Winters in Bay Shore are cold, with plenty of snow, while summers are warm and balmy, with breezes from the Atlantic Ocean to cool residents. Seniors sensitive to the cold may be uncomfortable here. 
  
• Bay Shore, as part of Suffolk County, is a member of the AARP Network of Age-Friendly Communities, meaning that its elected leadership “has made the commitment to actively work toward making their town, city or county a great place for people of all ages,” according to AARP.
• Overall crime rates for both property crimes and violent crimes are lower in Bay Shore than the rest of the nation, although seniors are still advised to use caution when venturing into New York City proper.  
  

Note: Data reported on this page was updated in 2019 and based on the latest 2018 figures.

Assisted Living costs in Bay Shore start around $7,095 per month on average, while the nationwide average cost of assisted living is $4,000 per month, according to the latest figures from Genworth’s Cost of Care Survey.

It’s important to note that assisted living rates in Bay Shore and the surrounding suburbs can vary widely based on factors such as location, the level of care needed, apartment size and the types of amenities offered at each community.

While many families use their own funds or personal assets to pay for assisted living, there are plenty of additional options to cover these costs. Some additional ways to finance assisted living costs include:

• Veterans Benefits
• Life Insurance Policy
• Long-Term Care Insurance
• Reverse Mortgage

For more information about different ways to finance assisted living, visit our Assisted Living in New York page.