Bay Shore has just over 29,000 residents, 10.5% of whom are in the 65+ age group (6% below the national average). It’s an ethnically diverse community with a wealth of boutique coffee shops, restaurants serving world cuisine and several popular parks. Seniors in the area pay approximately $5,339 for home care services, which, according to the 2021 Genworth Cost of Care Survey, is average for New York. Home care is a non-medical service that supports seniors struggling with daily living tasks and shouldn’t be confused with home health care, a home medical service. Seniors in Bay Shore who opt for home care have access to nearby South Shore University Hospital, which has been rated as high-performing in treating numerous conditions. 

Below we’ve compiled a comprehensive directory of every home care provider in the Bay Shore area – complete with services offered and reviews from families who’ve actually used the service. In addition to our in-depth provider listings, we’ve compiled resources to help seniors and their families to access all the tools they need to age in place safely and gracefully.

Directory of Home Care Services in Bay Shore, NY

2018, 2019, 2020, 2021, 2022

Right at Home South Shore Long Island

1111 Route 110, Suite 207, Farmingdale, NY, 11735

I can’t say enough about the great experience I had with Right at Home! I used them to provide companion care for my mom who was on Hospice care. Maria, the staff coordinator was friendly and did he … (read more)
I can’t say enough about the great experience I had with Right at Home! I used them to provide companion care for my mom who was on Hospice care. Maria, the staff coordinator was friendly and did he … (read more)

2018, 2019

Home Instead – Hauppauge, NY

900 Wheeler Rd, Suite 240, Hauppauge, NY, 11788

Pattie is always on top of everything. The quality of the women who have been hired is excellent. They have all seemed to be capable and caring. I am very happy that I chose Home Instead when I needed … (read more)
Pattie is always on top of everything. The quality of the women who have been hired is excellent. They have all seemed to be capable and caring. I am very happy that I chose Home Instead when I needed … (read more)

SeniorCare Companions, Inc.

150 Islip Ave., Suite 2, Islip, NY, 11751

Serving Manhattan to Montauk since 2004 <p></p> SeniorCare Companions was formed in 2004 by local Doctors who understand how important independent living is to seniors. Since that time, SeniorCare C … (read more)
Serving Manhattan to Montauk since 2004 <p></p> SeniorCare Companions was formed in 2004 by local Doctors who understand how important independent living is to seniors. Since that time, SeniorCare C … (read more)

Angel Care Home Companion Services, Inc

34 East Main Street Suite 430 , Smithtown, NY, 11787

Angel Care Home Companion Services- New York is an in-home care provider serving New York, New York and the surrounding area. Angel Care Home Companion Services- New York offers non-medical services i … (read more)
Angel Care Home Companion Services- New York is an in-home care provider serving New York, New York and the surrounding area. Angel Care Home Companion Services- New York offers non-medical services i … (read more)

Home Instead – Melville, NY

150 Broadhollow Rd, Suite 315, Huntington Station, NY, 11746

As soon as I indicated interest, I was immediately called to see if I had any questions. From the initial consultation through the placement of a caretaker, Home Instead has been professional, courte … (read more)
As soon as I indicated interest, I was immediately called to see if I had any questions. From the initial consultation through the placement of a caretaker, Home Instead has been professional, courte … (read more)

Senior Helpers – Central Long Island

115 Newbridge Road, Hicksville, NY, 11801

Senior Helpers in-home companion and personal care services focus on improving the health and well-being of your aging loved ones so they can get the most out of life. Whether you need assistance 24 … (read more)
Senior Helpers in-home companion and personal care services focus on improving the health and well-being of your aging loved ones so they can get the most out of life. Whether you need assistance 24 … (read more)

A Gentle Touch Senior Home Care

344 Deer Park Ave, Babylon, NY, 11702

A Gentle Touch Senior Home care is a family owned and operated home care agency servicing all of our families as both personally and professionally as possible. Who better to take care of your family … (read more)
A Gentle Touch Senior Home care is a family owned and operated home care agency servicing all of our families as both personally and professionally as possible. Who better to take care of your family … (read more)

Moskowitz Legal Group

1318 42nd Street, Brooklyn, NY, 11219


Family First Home Companions

1777 Veterans Memorial Hwy Ste 4 , Islandia, NY, 11749

Family First Home Companions provides caregiver companions to help seniors at home. Our goal is to provide a service that offers professional care, excellent customer service, and expertise in managin … (read more)
Family First Home Companions provides caregiver companions to help seniors at home. Our goal is to provide a service that offers professional care, excellent customer service, and expertise in managin … (read more)

TheKey – Suffolk County

7 South Jersey Ave. Suite 3, East Setauket, NY, 11733


2021, 2022

Elder Home Care

215 E Main St. , Suite 200B, Huntington, NY, 11743

The aide that they assign is very nice and is good with my mother. I like the aide that I have them through them.
The aide that they assign is very nice and is good with my mother. I like the aide that I have them through them.

2017

Companion Home Care of Long Island

904 5th Street, West Babylon, NY, 11704

Companion Home Care of LI has been a wonderful agency to work for. My husband and I were looking for a caretaker long distance as we are out of state. Our Mom was a very active 97 year old. We nee … (read more)
Companion Home Care of LI has been a wonderful agency to work for. My husband and I were looking for a caretaker long distance as we are out of state. Our Mom was a very active 97 year old. We nee … (read more)

Ellison Home Care Agency, Inc

1747 Veterans Memorial Highway, Ste. 44, Islandia, NY, 11749

I’ve had an excellent experience with Ellison Care from day one. I was stranded with somebody to take care of my father in-law who was not well and living at home. They called me back at 5.30 in the m … (read more)
I’ve had an excellent experience with Ellison Care from day one. I was stranded with somebody to take care of my father in-law who was not well and living at home. They called me back at 5.30 in the m … (read more)

Serendipity Senior Companion Care Inc

565 Route 25 A, Ste. LL2, Miller Place, NY, 11764

We want to thank you for the prompt call back on a Saturday morning. My mom was discharged from the Hospital and lived alone and we contacted Serendipity. We went into a panic mode. After the weekend … (read more)
We want to thank you for the prompt call back on a Saturday morning. My mom was discharged from the Hospital and lived alone and we contacted Serendipity. We went into a panic mode. After the weekend … (read more)

Homecare Therapies

20 Jerusalem Avenue, Hicksville, NY, 11801

My experience with Homecare Therapies was wonderful. They were attentive, caring, and highly professional. Would recommend to anyone in need.
My experience with Homecare Therapies was wonderful. They were attentive, caring, and highly professional. Would recommend to anyone in need.

The Handmaiden Services, Inc.

656 Newark Ave., Jersey City, NJ, 07306

The Handmaiden Services provided my mother and my father with excellent service. My mother passed away in February 2015. The Handmaiden Services also took care of my father after cancer surgery in 201 … (read more)
The Handmaiden Services provided my mother and my father with excellent service. My mother passed away in February 2015. The Handmaiden Services also took care of my father after cancer surgery in 201 … (read more)

Damen Companion Care

699 Acorn St, Deer Park, NY, 11729

I needed care for my mother and contacted them. They were wonderful from the first conversation, staff was very professional. The cost was also the best compared to others I called
I needed care for my mother and contacted them. They were wonderful from the first conversation, staff was very professional. The cost was also the best compared to others I called

Grace Companion Care

33B Country Club Drive, Coram, NY, 11727

When it was clear our 85 year old father needed support to continue to stay in his home, our research pointed us to Grace Senior Companion Care. We were very impressed with their compassion, caring a … (read more)
When it was clear our 85 year old father needed support to continue to stay in his home, our research pointed us to Grace Senior Companion Care. We were very impressed with their compassion, caring a … (read more)

Nannys For Grannys

34 Sunset Ln, Patchogue, NY, 11772

So many times aides didn’t show up &amp; we were never told they weren’t coming. Happened to have only two aides that we felt were good (which is why we gave two stars). Very frustrating dealing with … (read more)
So many times aides didn’t show up &amp; we were never told they weren’t coming. Happened to have only two aides that we felt were good (which is why we gave two stars). Very frustrating dealing with … (read more)

PearlCare Medical Staffing – Mamoroneck

434 Mamaroneck Avenue, Suite 101, Mamaroneck, NY, 10543

I first discovered PearlCare through the suggestion of one of my close friends who had used the service for her late step mother as she reached the end of her life. She loved the staff and the conveni … (read more)
I first discovered PearlCare through the suggestion of one of my close friends who had used the service for her late step mother as she reached the end of her life. She loved the staff and the conveni … (read more)

Paying for Home Care in Bay Shore, NY

The Cost of Home Care in Bay Shore, NY

Bay Shore’s older residents usually pay around $5,339 per month for home care services, which is typical for New York, although significantly more than the national average of $4,957. New York City is costlier, at $5,529, while Poughkeepsie’s average is also $5,339, and Kingston is a more affordable $5,148. The 2021 Genworth Cost of Care Survey found Bay Shore’s average fees are higher than most cities on the opposite side of Long Island Sound too, such as in New Haven, Connecticut, where the average fee is $5,243. 

$5339

Bay Shore

$4576

New York

$4957

The United States

$5529

New York City

$5339

Poughkeepsie

$5148

Kingston

$5243

New Haven, CT

The Cost of Home Care vs. Other Senior Care Options in Bay Shore, NY

Seniors can expect to pay around $5,339 per month for both home care and home health care services in Bay Shore. Neither service is as affordable as adult day care ($1,619), but both are less costly than assisted living ($6,273) and a semiprivate room in a nursing home, where $16,805 per month is the norm.

$5339

Home Care

$5339

Home Health Care

$1619

Adult Day Health Care

$6273

Assisted Living Facility

$16805

Nursing Home Facility (semiprivate room)

Note: Data for Bay Shore was unavailable, so data for the nearest city, Bridgeport, CT, was used instead.

Financial Assistance for Home Care in Bay Shore, NY

Given the high cost of in-home care, many people use one or more forms of financial assistance to cover the expenses. Below, we explain some of the most common sources of financial help for paying for in-home care. If none of these options are available to you, you can reach out to your Area Agency on Aging or Aging and Disability Resource Center to learn about local resources.

  • Long-Term Care Insurance: Long-Term Care Insurance covers expenses related to senior care, including in-home care. Depending on the policy type, beneficiaries may receive a cash payment to use towards long-term care or reimbursement for qualifying long-term care expenses. Note that there are limitations- typically a maximum benefit of $150 per day- and exact coverage terms vary depending on the exact policy, so always check the details.
  • Medicare: Medicare does not cover in-home care because it is classified as custodial, or non-medical, care. However, some Medicare Advantage and Medicare Supplement plans, which offer expanded benefits, may cover in-home custodial care.
  • Medicaid: Medicaid coverage of in-home care varies between different states because it is not a federally mandated benefit. Currently, all states cover some in-home care either through their standard Medicaid or a waiver program. The specific coverage rules are set individually by each state.
  • Veterans’ Benefits: The Aid and Attendance benefit is a monthly cash payment that beneficiaries can use to pay for senior care, including in-home care services. To qualify for A&A, Veterans must already receive the VA pension and meet several additional requirements, including needing assistance with the activities of daily living.Contact the Department of Veterans Affairs to learn more.
  • Reverse Mortgages: Home Equity Conversion Mortgages (HECMs) are federally insured loans that are available to homeowners age 62 and over. Reverse mortgages allow you to access a portion of your home’s equity in cash, tax free. Many seniors use reverse mortgages to finance their care expenses, including in-home care. Note that although there are no monthly payments due on reverse mortgage loans, borrowers do have to repay the loan once the last surviving homeowner passes away, moves, or sells the home.

Free & Low-Cost Home Care Resources in Bay Shore, NY

Bay Shore’s seniors needn’t face emergencies alone, as many nonprofits and other agencies provide free assistance to Suffolk County residents. The resources listed here can help make homes safer, assist with energy costs, provide healthy meals and loan durable medical equipment.

Resource

Contact

Service

(631) 471-1215

The Community Development Corporation of Long Island is a nonprofit that uses funds from the New York State Affordable Housing Corporation to pay home repair costs for income-eligible residents of Suffolk County. The program's purpose is to make homes safer and more comfortable, which may mean the repair or replacement of heating systems, roofs, siding and gutters, as well as the installation of features that can make the home more energy-efficient, such as windows, doors and wall insulation. 

(631) 880-7929

The Suffolk Independent Living Organization is an advocacy agency dedicated to helping seniors continue to live at home. Its support functions include TRAID, a technology-related assistance program for people with disabilities. The program has a wide scope that includes loaning equipment to residents on low incomes and providing technical assistance and training.  

(631) 854-9935

Suffolk County's Home Heating Assistance Program is available to seniors, people on low incomes and anyone at risk of being unable to cover their home heating costs. The program usually pays the successful applicant's vendor directly and can cover the cost of home-heating fuels. Seniors who need help completing an application can get assistance from the Office for the Aging at (631) 853-8326.

(631) 789-5219

Catholic Charities of Long Island manages a Meals on Wheels program for seniors throughout Suffolk and Nassau counties, delivering hot and nutritionally balanced meals Monday to Friday. The program's case managers may also be able to help seniors access other local programs they could be eligible for. 

(631) 842-6100  

The Economic Opportunity Council of Suffolk, Inc. operates an emergency assistance program that supports eligible residents financially struggling because of the COVID-19 pandemic. The program may be able to help people with their rent or mortgage, car payments and health insurance. Additionally, it can support those who are two or more months behind on their utility payments or are facing an unexpected heating emergency, such as a broken furnace.

Determining Your Loved One’s Need for In-Home Care

Aging can be a difficult process, and loved ones may not always ask for help – oftentimes it’s up to their family to evaluate their need for help around the house. While no two situations are exactly alike, this checklist can help you and your loved ones determine when it’s time to start the search for a home care provider.

Checklist for determining the need for home care


Guidelines for Talking About In-Home Care

If you’ve determined that your loved one needs the assistance of a care provider in their home, it may be time for a difficult conversation. Handled correctly, however, this process can bring a family together and ensure that everyone’s concerns are addressed. Use this PDF as a starting point to help the conversation stay as positive and productive as possible.

Talking with Family and Others about a loved one's needs

Frequently Asked Questions


How do you pay for senior care at home?


Home care is frequently paid from the senior’s personal funds, which can be their savings, support from family members or a reverse mortgage. Some may be able to get limited assistance from Medicare, depending on their plan, while those eligible for Medicaid may be eligible for the Personal Care Services Program. An annuity is another possibility, although it will require the senior to pay a lump sum (or installments) in advance to the insurance provider, which will then gradually release the funds at a later date to cover home care costs.


What is the average cost for in-home elderly care in Bay Shore?


According to the 2021 Genworth Cost of Care Survey, the average fee for home care in Bay Shore is $5,339 per month. However, fees vary depending on the number of services the agency provides and its pricing structure. For example, a senior receiving standard services, such as help with bathing, isn’t likely to pay as much as someone who gets that service as well as housekeeping and grocery shopping assistance. Other factors can also affect fees, such as caregivers staying overnight.


How can I find home care agencies near me with availability?


A simple and quick way is to visit the Caring.com home care services page for Bay Shore. It lists agencies that serve the city’s older residents, includes star-approval ratings by seniors or their loved ones and has links to each provider, where visitors can read more information about their services. The link also reveals the agency’s current availability, potential costs and payment options, as well as content about specialty services, such as support for seniors with memory loss conditions. 


Who is eligible for the veterans’ home care program?


Any senior who served in the armed services is eligible for the veterans’ home care program, as is their spouse. The vet can apply for regular home care services or temporary help in the absence of their family caregiver, or they may be able to combine the program with a home and community-based service provided through Medicaid. Veteran Directed Care may suit other seniors, as it offers much the same services, but the senior chooses their caregivers and pays them directly via the program’s funds. 


What to expect with hospice care at home?


Although each agency is unique, it’s common for a case manager to direct all hospice care services. These typically include personalizing the service for the senior and their family as much as possible and altering the assistance provided as needs change. Team members who visit regularly typically include home health aides, chaplains, therapists and specialists, as required. The case manager will also ensure all medical equipment is delivered to the home and monitored and maintained.