Hickory Creek at Sunset
1109 S INDIANA ST, Greencastle, IN 46135
Community Reviews and Comparisions

Featured Review
Vickie
5
|
March 18, 2026
My mom is a current resident. She's is long term. She has been there for over a month. The staff is very attentive and caring. They are quick to answer a call light. Her room is very nice with plenty of space. She shares a bathroom. It is never a problem getting in for her. PT is available for her, though at this point, she's not a fan. They work with her dementia and keep me updated. The food is her favorite thing. And she is a picky eater. The administration staff is very helpful and always there to discuss anything that needs attention. The nursing staff is also attentive to her needs. The entire facility has a wonderful staff and the facility is well maintained.
For personalized guidance, current availability, add help scheduling a tour, call our Caring Family Advisors at (844) 674-3623
About Hickory Creek at Sunset in Greencastle, Indiana
Hickory Creek at Sunset, located in Greencastle, IN, offers a variety of care options, including skilled nursing care, respite care, hospice care, and short-term rehabilitation care. This makes it a versatile choice for individuals with diverse health needs.The community features several amenities designed to enhance the living experience. Residents have access to outdoor common areas and walking and hiking paths, which are ideal for fresh air and exercise. Mobility and wheelchair assistance are available to ensure residents can move around comfortably. Communal dining is also provided, allowing residents to enjoy meals together.Hickory Creek at Sunset offers a range of services to support residents' health and well-being. Nurses are on staff to provide medical care, and physical therapy and rehabilitation services are available for those recovering from injuries or surgeries. Occupational therapy and rehabilitation are also offered to help residents maintain their daily living skills. Additionally, therapists are on staff to provide specialized care and support.
Consider Nearby Options
Not sure where to start?
Talk to a Caring expert now
Free Expert Advice
We guide you through the overwhelming process of finding quality care.
Recommendations
We'll match you with the right care providers—no pressure, no cost.
Tour Scheduling
We manage key details for you like booking tours and follow-ups.
Reviews of Hickory Creek at Sunset in Greencastle, Indiana
3.1
(6 reviews)
Facility
3.8
Staff
3.8
Food
3.0
Activities
3.8
Value
4.0
Vickie
5
|
March 18, 2026
My mom is a current resident. She's is long term. She has been there for over a month. The staff is very attentive and caring. They are quick to answer a call light. Her room is very nice with plenty of space. She shares a bathroom. It is never a problem getting in for her. PT is available for her, though at this point, she's not a fan. They work with her dementia and keep me updated. The food is her favorite thing. And she is a picky eater. The administration staff is very helpful and always there to discuss anything that needs attention. The nursing staff is also attentive to her needs. The entire facility has a wonderful staff and the facility is well maintained.
Roberta
1
|
January 28, 2025
I didn't like Hickory Creek at Sunset's patient-to-caregiver ratio at all. The beds did not have bed rails, so my husband fell out of bed immediately. There weren't people there to help my husband, and people were rarely there to help him get to the bathroom. The call button went unanswered for 40 minutes. It was a total disaster as far as we were concerned. My husband was there for two days. There were few staff members, and they were overworked. I think they were not as interested in the patients as they were in maintaining the pretense of being adequate. They gave my husband an individual pizza. However, he had fallen in the hospital, and he had broken two teeth, and the pizza was too difficult to cut up for him to eat, so the diet wasn't specific to him. They made no consideration for the fact that he wasn't going to be able to chew it, and they didn't have any substitutes to offer. They said they had activities, but I wasn't there during any activities. I found my husband by himself seated in a wheelchair when there was supposed to be an activity. He was by himself in their little dining area, which is where they had activities. He had dozed off in the wheelchair and was sagged over to the side. There was no seat belt in the wheelchair, so he could have fallen out, and there was no help around at all. There was no one in the room. There were several other patients in the room, but they would not have been able to help him.
Frank Castle
5
|
October 29, 2023
I had my Grandfather here to rehabilitate after surgery. He was at Hickory Creek for two months. I would have to say that getting him in here was a breeze with the nice lady that does admissions and the Director Tega. I really appreciate all the help they gave and how easy they made the transition. The nursing staff was great to him, and physical therapy had him up and going with in a couple of weeks. Everyone I encountered were very nice and attentive to the needs of my grandfather. He also like having his own room to himself.
sonpa
1
|
March 10, 2023
Always out of supplies. Food cold most of the time. Unhealthy food chooses. Lots of bread, white gravy and pasta served. Lots of processed meat which is high in sodium. Staff frustrated by low pay and not enough workers. Most of the workers are kind and do their best with the conditions they work under. I do not recommend this facility.
LS1
4
|
July 13, 2015
My husband had broken his hip, so I had to find a place for him fast. I had put him in one place, which was a good place, but it was really rather expensive, so I had to get something that was a little cheaper and still had a good rating. And caring.com gave me Hickory Creek; I went over and checked it out, and I thought, "Well, it is small, it's OK, the price was definitely right, and it still has a good rating." So I moved him into there, and he seems to be doing well. He has Alzheimer's, he is in the last stages, and he is actually kind of laughing a lot and interacting with people more than he did, so this is a really nice place. The staff is absolutely fine. They already know my name, they know his name, and it is just great. The only reason I give them a four is because they don't have soft drinks, and my husband enjoys soft drinks.
KFC2012
3
|
April 25, 2012
Hickory Creek was a decent facility for the most part. The staff were very kind. However, to exit the building, you had to punch in a code on a keypad. The code was changed every day. When I would go to leave, there was never anyone at the front desk, therefore I could not get out of the building until I searched around and found someone or another visitor was kind enough to let me know the exit code for the day. Another issue is that I found the patient rooms way to small. My Uncle was in a two-individual room, and both of them barely had room to walk around their beds.
Medicare
Health
3.0
Overall
4.0
Quality
5.0
Staff
2.0
More Communities to Explore
What you can do with Caring
Helpful Articles
Senior Living near Greencastle, IN
Senior Living near Putnam County, IN
Other options in Greencastle, IN
Help us keep this review accurate
Our reviews and comparisons help families make confident decisions. If you represent this community, you can submit updates so details stay current, complete, and transparent
Updates do not automatically change review scores or rankings. Submissions are reviewed fo accuracy and clarity.






