Which is better? Power of attorney or guardianship?

2 answers | Last updated: Nov 02, 2016
Jerrytomas asked...

Which is more advantages - a durable power of attorney or a guardianship? My sister has convinced my father to go with a guardianship. Does the guardianship stay in effect after my father's death?

Expert Answers

Barbara Repa, a Caring.com senior editor, is an attorney, a journalist specializing in aging issues, and the author of Your Rights in the Workplace (Nolo), now in its 10th edition.

Both legal arrangements"”naming an agent in a power of attorney and setting up a legal guardianship"”accomplish basically the same thing: They authorize a person to manage and control another person's finances and sometimes medical care for another person.

Which one you or your sister seek may depend more on your father's condition and mental state than anything else.

Guardianships are more difficult to secure. They require petitioning a court and pleading and proving that the person for whom you seek a guardianship is no longer able to care for his or her own affairs. Close relatives are notified and able to come to court to support or contest the arrangement. And it can be somewhat embarrassing for some people, as it is a public forum and an admission of some basic inabilities that some would rather keep private.

A power of attorney, on the other hand, is easier to secure"”and require only completing and filing a few forms with the local court. The catch may be that to get one, your father would have to agree and participate"”and he can legally do this only if he has the required mental capacity. In the eyes of the law, this means he must understand the nature, scope and effect of the document.

Both a power of attorney and guardianship end with the death of the person for whom they were secured. Your father would need to need an executor in a will or a trustee in a trust to have power to manage his money and other property after his death.

Community Answers

Tested but trying answered...

I have recently gained conservatorship for my Dad and believe me, it is best to have a power of attorney if possible. The court requires a bond for the assets of my Dad. The bond is an added cost and a drain on his assets. The annual premium is approx. n $ 3000.00... That is approx. $ 250.00/mo. Also an accounting of his funds must be filed annually and it is my understanding that there will be a court charge for auditing of the accounts each year. In the meantime, I am providing all his physical care, transporting him to appointments, performing all other tasks necessary for him .. cooking, cleaning, bathing, shopping, etc and I cannot use any of his money to compensate me for my caregiving even though I have been forced to give up any outside employment in order to care for him.

Our laws are definitely off kilter ... it seems that the people who have not planned for old age get all the benefits while the courts drain the resources of the people who have scraped by and saved.