LifeFone vs LifeStation
Medical alert systems are designed to help seniors remain as independent as possible while ensuring help is always available. These compact, wireless devices connect with a monitored call center over landline phones or cellular networks, and newer models now feature additional services, such as GPS locating, automatic fall detection, and temperature sensing.
While medical alert systems can’t prevent medical emergencies, they can dramatically increase the odds that loved ones and first responders are able to provide immediate assistance. Most help buttons are designed to be completely waterproof, allowing users to wear them while showering or outside in rainy weather. In fact, these devices have been proven to help seniors stay safe — that’s why many insurance companies, and some Medicaid plans, cover the costs of monthly medical alert monitoring services.
To help you choose the right system for your loved one, we’ve collected in-depth information on the most popular medical alert systems and devices on the market today.
This guide compares two systems, LifeStation and LifeFone. Both of these companies are based in the United States and offer similar services, however, there are some notable differences in pricing and features that are worth considering.
|Side by Side Comparison||MobileHelp||Lifestation|
$349.95 for Smartwatch
|Monthly Monitoring||$19.95 - $41.95|
+ $10/month for optional fall detection
+ $2/month for optional wall-mounted help buttons
+ $5/month for optional customizable medication reminders
|$19.95 - $41.95
+ $10/month for fall detection with In-Home packages
+ $5/month for Mobile package
|Activation Fee||N/A||$50 for Mobile GPS Standard plan only|
|Contract||Monthly, quarterly, semi-annually or annually|
*Monthly payments require a one-time fee of $49.95
$0 cancellation fee
|Optional Monthly Add-On Services||$2/month for optional wall-mounted help buttons|
$5/month for optional customizable medication reminders
|$10/month for fall detection with In-Home packages or $5/month for Mobile package|
|Water-Resistant Wearable Devices||Pendant and wristband||Pendant and wristband|
|Connection||Cellular via AT&T network||Landline and Cellular via AT&T network|
|2-Way Voice Communication||Yes||Yes|
|Range (From in-home base unit for landline service)||600' from home base for mobile devices||650' for In-Home Plus
1,000' for In-Home Traditional
|Battery life||24 hours for mobile device|
30-hour backup for home base
48 hours/charge for the smartwatch
|48-hour backup for home bases
5 days/charge for mobile device
|FALL DETECTION, LOCATION and RESPONSE SERVICE|
|Fall Detection||Additional $10/month|
*not available with smartwatch
|Additional $10/month for fall detection with In-Home packages or $5/month for Mobile package|
|GPS Locator||Included with mobile devices||Included with mobile devices|
|Coverage Away From Home||Nationwide via AT&T cellular network||Throughout the US and Canada|
|24/7 USA Call Center||Yes: via Rapid Response||Yes: located in New Jersey and Texas|
|Wall-mounted help button - $2/month|
Customizable medication reminders - $5/month
Lockbox - included with plan
|Mountable help buttons - $2.49/month
Additional help button - $3.99/month
Lockbox - $2.99/month
Based in White Plains, NY, LifeFone is one of the oldest and most recognized names in medical alert systems. The U.S.-based call center is owned and operated by the company, and there are two back-up call centers to ensure that no call for help goes unanswered. LifeFone offers landline- and cellular-connected devices for at-home and on the go.
LifeFone stands out against the competition for its add-on options that are designed to provide day-to-day support for seniors who want to remain as independent as possible. These extra features, such as daily safety checks, fire/smoke detection, and personalized care instructions, are designed to give seniors and their loved ones extra protection and security that goes above and beyond what many other medical alert systems offer.
Pros of LifeFone:
- Established U.S. company
- Free lifetime replacement of defective devices
- Small, waterproof user-friendly devices
- No limit on the number of emergency contacts
- Free second user at the same address
- No contracts — users can cancel at any time
- Prices are locked-in, so once a user subscribes, their cost won’t increase
Cons of LifeFone:
- Users must replace batteries for call buttons themselves, which can be difficult for seniors and people with low vision
- Wrist button available in black only
Established in 1977, LifeStation offers in-home and mobile medical alert systems that connect users to a U.S.-based call center at the touch of a button on either the pendant or wrist-worn help button. A 30-day money-back guarantee is included for all systems, and there are no long-term contracts.
LifeStation’s call center is UL-listed and staffed by five-diamond rated call operators who have completed advanced training in medical alert call answering. Plans start at less than $1 per day, making this one of the more affordable options on the market.
Pros of LifeStation:
- Setup can be completed in 5 minutes by the user
- Every LifeStation medical alert system is tested weekly by the call center
- Equipment repair and replacement is included in monthly fees
- Offers a $25 American Express prepaid card as a referral bonus
- Optional wireless help buttons available
- Additional help button can be added for a spouse or roommate for a small monthly fee
- Advanced fall detection and GPS locating
- Pendant can be used to answer landline phone calls through the in-home base station
Cons of LifeStation:
- Pricing is difficult to understand – prices are not fully disclosed upfront, so potential customers must call for current prices
- Range of 500′ between the base unit and the help button is less than many other medical alert systems
- Unclear if service is available in languages other than English
Pricing for both systems is comparable and each company offers add-ons, such as lockboxes, wall-mounted buttons, and automatic fall detection. Shipping is also free with both systems, and users are able to set up their own help buttons without paying an extra fee or needing a technician to come to their home.
Although both LifeFone and LifeStation offer similar services and devices, we prefer the transparency in pricing offered by LifeFone. Users can quickly check the prices on the website before subscribing, while LifeStation only discloses the price of their basic service on their website. Seniors may have difficulty understanding the pricing and service options over the phone for LifeStation, and as a result, they may wind up paying for products and services they don’t want or need.
When comparing these two medical alert systems, we recommend LifeFone over LifeStation. As a longstanding company that offers consumer-friendly price plans, proven medical alert devices and a wide variety of medical alert solutions that operate using either a landline or cellular connection, LifeFone consistently receives high ratings from actual users.
We also like that LifeFone has an A+ rating with the Better Business Bureau and offers an impressive 1300′ range from the in-home base unit. All of their equipment is backed by a lifetime warranty, and the company offers current users one month of free service for everyone they refer.
Compare More Medical Alert Systems
Click on the links below to read about Medical Alert system comparisons.
- Alert1 vs Life Alert
- Alert1 vs MobileHelp
- Bay Alarm Medical vs GreatCall
- Bay Alarm Medical vs Philips Lifeline
- Greatcall vs Medical Guardian
- Life Alert vs Bay Alarm Medical
- Life Alert vs Medical Alert
- Life Alert vs Medical Guardian
- Life Alert vs Q Medic
- LifeFone vs LifeStation
- LifeStation vs ResponseNow
- Medical Guardian vs Bay Alarm Medical
- Medical Guardian vs Medical Care Alert
- MobileHelp vs Bay View Medical
- MobileHelp vs GreatCall
- MobileHelp vs Life Alert
- MobileHelp vs Lifestation
- Philips Lifeline vs LifeFone
- Rescue Alert vs Alert1
- ResponseNow vs GreatCall