My spouse and I dealt with the problem of “driving while incompetent” with only one of our four parents. After my father-in-law was in his upper 80s his short-term memory, problem-solving ability, and vision all deteriorated significantly. His car acquired scrapes and paint of unknown origin on its four corners. We initially used logical arguments to encourage my father-in-law to stop driving. Of course the man agreed with everything we said, then did whatever he wanted to do. Then he would occasionally disappear with his car for hours, but when asked where he had been he’d reply “I’d tell you if I knew.” We contacted the DMV, which issued him a restricted license that allowed him to drive only between his house and the local restaurant / bar in our active-adult community. Well, do you think the license restriction changed his driving habits? Of course not! Eventually (after doctors diagnosed my father-in-law’s dementia) the DMV acknowledged that my father-in-law’s driving skills were questionable and invited him for testing, which he failed. The DMV revoked his license. Do you think that had any impact on his behavior? Of course not! The local police phoned us one night when they found him driving very slowly after dark while he was trying to read street signs. Did that have any effect on his driving habits? Did the police even check whether he had a valid license? Of course not! Then, some of our friends alerted us that my father-in-law was driving erratically through the neighborhood. Finally, we realized that we were the only ones who could force him to stop driving. Nobody else was going to do it for us.
So, although long reluctant to take this step, we disabled my father-in-law’s car to prevent him from driving again. We could, of course, appreciate his perspective. As one ages, a person’s world shrinks ever smaller. Health deteriorates, friends and relatives become house-bound or die, disposable income shrinks, apparent distances to destinations become greater, technology outpaces comprehension, and (in the USA) alternative methods of transportation for the elderly never materialize. Elders gradually lose control of everything that seems to matter, and depression often follows.
We promised to provide transportation whenever he needed it but, as we feared, my father-in-law was extremely angry and bitter. I’m afraid he never forgave us. He was an “independent” man who seemed to carry grudges “forever.” Eventually my father-in-law reluctantly gave his car to his son. Our solution to the “driving while incompetent” problem became unavoidable but it proved not to be a good one in terms of our relationship with my father-in-law. But, the good thing is that he never injured himself or another person with his car.